Over 25 years of business, we've opened many stores across the tri-state area. While every store proudly represents our SUPER! AMAZING! WOW! experience, our Shirley store exemplifies the best deals, selection, and quality Best Market is known for.
A Few Reasons You'll Love It:
- The Local Selection - We pride ourselves on sourcing as much as possible from local farmers, bakers, butchers, and makers from New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut.
- Happy Team Members = Happy Customers. We make sure our team is taken care of (a great starting wage, 401K, & benefits) so they take even better care of you!
- Quality Is King - if we wouldn't eat it or buy it, you won't see it on our shelves. We bring you the best quality at the best prices.
Committed To Quality
The focus here is fresh foods, especially produce, meat, seafood, deli, dairy and bakery items, as well as traditional grocery store items. Every store is fully equipped with a skilled and talented team of hard working individuals whom we trust to provide our super! amazing! wow! experience to our customers each and every day.
The Freshest Produce
Just like Best Yet Market and Produce Warehouse before it, Best Market has built and maintained its reputation for having the finest quality hand-selected produce available. Years in the business and relationships we’ve built over time means we’re the first to know when a product is available, and the ‘first dibbs’ on it! Shirley is going to love our local, organic, and always fresh options!
Shirley has never seen a meat department like ours! From steaks to chops to ground in-house meats and gourmet sausages, every Best Market meat department is full of customer favorites that are always fresh and never frozen. We’ll help you find the cut you need at a price you’ll love. If we have it, we’ll cut it. Filets, roasts, chops—we’ll custom cut your meat, all you have to do is ask.
The Best Seafood
Our ultra-fresh catch comes in at docks from Montauk, Freeport, and other local areas - all fresh from the Atlantic. With so many locations nearby, there are times we bring in fish that has been out of the water for less than an hour! Choose from a vast selection of wild caught, aqua cultured, local, gourmet prepared and more!
We’re here to give Shirley the best choices and biggest variety in cold cuts, meats, cheeses and more with team members committed to value and service. On top of regular supermarket favorites, our delis stock natural, organic, and Kosher items to meet your family’s needs, too. Day in, day out, there’s delicious variety to be found at our deli!
Baked With Love - The Bakery
From artisan bread to cakes and sweet treats, each member of our bakery team works hard to ensure the items they sell are beautiful and delicious no matter the occasion. Whether you’re looking for your family’s favorite bread, the perfect treat for a special occasion, or just a cup of coffee to savor a moment in your busy day, Best Market's bakery will give you everything you’re looking for at a great price.
Grocery, Dairy & Frozen Fun
With all the charm and freshness of a traditional market alongside a variety and selection to match any supermarket, whatever you need, the odds are good you'll find it! We are committed to serving all our customers’ needs, so we stock a full range of products, including organics, gluten free items, imported, kosher and ethnic foods, and even some specialty items for your secret recipes.